Hey Flock, I have a few questions for you. I have been over-thinking the story lines of movies again and I am wondering if others picked on these things, too. Today's movie for over-analysis is Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl. This is the first movie in the series and where we are all introduced to the characters of Cap'n Jack, Elizabeth, and Will.
I practically have the movie memorized as I have watched it more times than I can count. It's a fun movie that I put on for background noise or as a time filler on occasion. The musical score is nice to hear and I like nautical themed movies. It is not a deep introspective portrayal of the human condition or anything deep. Come on, it's Disney.
So here's my question and I have pondered this from the first time I watched it. Here's the scene, Will and Elizabeth are on the Dauntless and being chased by the pirates on the Black Pearl. The crew that is manning the Dauntless is a seasoned crew of sailors with many years of experience at sea and on many different vessels. The Black Pearl is gaining on the Dauntless and the crew expresses how "there's nothing we can do, we can only try to outrun them". It is at this point in the story where our lead female character and lead male character, both equally beautiful/handsome and deliver their lines perfectly, chime in with evasion tactics and nautical knowledge that "the crew never thought of".
Here is where I have a problem. These two land lubbers who have only been passengers on ships and have spent most of their lives pursuing vocations that have nothing to do with the sea, are suddenly the idea people for "how to escape pirates". Will Turner had been a blacksmith the last eight years and certainly had little to no contact with ships crews unless he hung out at taverns and acted as the odd guy that wants to be a sailor but never does. Elizabeth had been raised as a girl of the upper class whose only schooling involved "how to marry rich men" and "which fork to use with which course at dinner". She may have been regaled with a few sea tales by officers of the Navy over wine and roast duck, but defensive/evasive tactics of sea battles was probably not discussed.
So like I said, I over-think movies sometimes and yes, the best movie plots don't always make the most sense. What are the movies that you like to over-think?
Flamingo Girl
How about Finding Dory? Just saw it. The original came out in 2003. Why is Nemo still a little kid 13 years later?
ReplyDeleteI don't know, haven't seen it yet. But that is odd for Nemo to still be a kid after so long. Also, what is the life expectancy of a clown fish? Surely not 13 years but I am not an expert on salt water fish. I would have to consult the almighty Google for that answer.
ReplyDelete